Back to Blog

Who Really Runs Your Emergency Department?

Lindsey Love

The hospital name is on the building. The hospital board answers to the community. But if an outside group staffs the emergency department, that shapes how much input and influence the hospital really has on its own Emergency Department (ED).

Most hospital leaders did not choose that arrangement; it is inherited. Outsourcing the ED solved a real problem at the time: coverage. The question worth asking now: Does the contract still meet the hospital's needs at a justifiable cost?

More than one in four emergency departments

In September, the Private Equity Stakeholder Project counted the emergency departments staffed by the largest contract groups. Its finding: companies backed by private equity staff at least 27% of U.S. emergency departments. Five firms account for 1,199 of the roughly 4,400 hospitals with emergency services, and the three largest staffing companies in the country are all investor-owned.

That is not an argument that every contract group delivers poor care. Many of the clinicians working those shifts are excellent. It is a reminder of who the business ultimately answers to. An investor-owned staffing company has to produce a return, and that return comes out of the contract with your hospital.

What you hand over with the contract

When the ED is outsourced, three things leave the building along with the staffing headaches.

Control. The staffing group hires, schedules, and replaces your providers. You can ask for a change in coverage, a different medical director, or a provider who fits your culture better. You cannot decide it.

Money. The margin on your emergency department goes to the contractor, and in many hospitals a subsidy goes with it. When the contract renews, the usual direction of the fee is up.

Continuity. The providers work for the group, not for you. If the group loses the contract, restructures, or walks away, the people your community knows can leave with it. Three hospitals in Maine are living this now: their emergency physician group will stop providing coverage on January 12, 2027, and the health system is still in talks with replacement groups.

Why this lands harder in a small hospital

A large system can absorb a bad contract. A critical access or community hospital often cannot. The emergency department is the front door for most admissions, the service the community judges you by, and one of the largest lines in the budget.

In a town with one hospital, the ED physician is also a neighbor. When that role is filled by a rotating cast of travelers, patients notice, nurses notice, and the primary care doctors who rely on the ED notice. And every dollar of margin that leaves for a corporate office in another state is a dollar not spent on nurses, equipment, or keeping a service line open.

There is a middle path

Hospital leaders often see only two choices: keep the contract, or bring the program in-house and take on recruiting, scheduling, credentialing, and physician leadership with a team that is already stretched. The second option sounds right and feels impossible.

Insourcing with a management partner is the third option.

At In-House Medical (IHM), the model is simple: your hospital employs and pays its providers. They are your people, on your team, accountable to your leadership. We run the practice day to day. Recruiting, scheduling, operations, and leadership development are our job. The margin stays with the hospital.

  • We charge a management fee. We do not take the program's revenue.
  • Our management fee decreases as the program stabilizes. A stable program takes less work. That equates to lower costs, and IHM passes that on to you.
  • The goal is to be a stepping stone. We transition the program, stabilize it, and leave the hospital with a model it can run on its own when it has the staff and confidence to do so.

Start with one question

Before your next contract renewal, ask yourself one question: if we ended our ED staffing agreement tomorrow, how many of our emergency providers would choose to stay?

If the honest answer is "I don't know" or "none of them," you do not run your emergency department. You rent it.

Next week, we follow the money: What an outsourced ED really costs a small hospital, and where those dollars go.

Want to see what insourcing would look like at your hospital?

Contact Lindsey Love at In-House Medical for a no-obligation conversation.

hospital medicineprivate equity in medicinecritical accessemergency departmentrural healthinsourcing
In-House Medical

In-House Medical is a model for dignifying the care of the patient by recognizing our purpose to serve and impart integrity to our fellow man. We create innovative, effective hospital-based provider practices by integrating our services into the fabric of the facility.

Company

Contact

In-House Medical

© 2026 In-House Medical. All rights reserved.